Smart Jewish Studies

Six Thinking hats and s.m.a.r.t goals

—

by

Kevin
in ,

 

Six Thinking Hats and Anavah (Humility)

The Six Thinking Hats framework, developed by Edward de Bono, provides a structured method for approaching anavah (humility) by examining it from different perspectives: logic, emotion, creativity, caution, benefits, and process. Below is an analysis of how each “hat” can explore the light and shadow aspects of anavah and detailed SMART goals for integrating these insights.

White Hat (Facts and Information)

Light Aspect:

    • Focuses on factual self-assessment and understanding one’s place (makir et mekomo). Humility here involves an honest appraisal of strengths and limitations.

Shadow Aspect:

    • Overemphasis on data may lead to a rigid or mechanical understanding of humility, neglecting emotional and relational dimensions.

SMART Goal:Ground Humility in Self-Awareness through Reflection

    • Observation: Humility often requires accurate self-knowledge.
    • Feeling: A need for clarity about strengths and weaknesses.
    • Need: To practice anavah based on a truthful self-assessment.
    • Request: Dedicate time to identifying areas of strength and growth.

SMART Goal: Specific: Spend 10 minutes weekly reflecting on a specific success or challenge, noting what role humility played.

    • Measurable: Record insights in a journal weekly.
    • Achievable: Start with easily observable situations (e.g., work or family interactions).
    • Relevant: Aligns with tzniut (modesty) and seder (order).
    • Timely: Begin within one week and evaluate progress after a month.

Red Hat (Emotion and Intuition)

Light Aspect:

    • Humility connects to emotional intelligence, fostering empathy (hakarat hatov) and deepening interpersonal relationships.

Shadow Aspect:

    • Over-reliance on emotion may lead to excessive humility, self-doubt, or fear of expressing oneself.

SMART Goal: Balance Emotional Awareness in Humility

    • Observation: Emotions can either deepen or undermine humility depending on balance.
    • Feeling: A desire for emotional attunement that supports humility.
    • Need: To connect with emotions without letting them dominate.
    • Request: Regularly check in with emotions during interactions.

SMART Goal: Specific: Practice an emotional “pause” during one conversation daily, identifying your feelings and how they influence humility.

    • Measurable: Track one instance daily where you consciously paused to reflect on emotions.
    • Achievable: Begin with low-stakes interactions.
    • Relevant: Supports menuchat hanefesh (calmness) and emotional balance.
    • Timely: Begin immediately and review weekly.

Black Hat (Caution and Risk Assessment)

Light Aspect:

    • Encourages awareness of humility’s potential pitfalls, such as passivity or being taken advantage of.

Shadow Aspect:

    • Excessive caution may prevent action, reinforcing passivity or fear of stepping into leadership roles.

SMART Goal: Address Risks of Misapplied Humility

    • Observation: Misapplied humility can lead to passivity or burnout.
    • Feeling: A concern about losing assertiveness or agency.
    • Need: To balance humility with action and self-respect.
    • Request: Identify one area where you avoid action due to fear of appearing arrogant.

SMART Goal: Specific: Identify and take one assertive action weekly that aligns with your values but challenges your comfort zone (e.g., speaking up in a meeting).

    • Measurable: Log the actions and outcomes weekly.
    • Achievable: Start with low-stakes situations.
    • Relevant: Reinforces anavah by balancing humility with proactive responsibility.
    • Timely: Begin within one week and assess progress after one month.

Yellow Hat (Optimism and Benefits)

Light Aspect:

    • Highlights the benefits of humility, such as improved relationships, personal growth, and alignment with divine values.

Shadow Aspect:

    • Overemphasis on positivity may ignore humility’s challenges, leading to superficial or performative practice.

SMART Goal: Celebrate the Benefits of Humility

    • Observation: Recognizing humility’s benefits can reinforce its practice.
    • Feeling: A desire to celebrate humility’s positive impact.
    • Need: To integrate gratitude for humility’s role in life.
    • Request: Regularly reflect on how humility has improved your relationships or self-growth.

SMART Goal: Specific: Write down one benefit of practicing humility weekly and share it in a conversation or journal.

    • Measurable: Record reflections weekly for at least three months.
    • Achievable: Begin with recent examples from personal or professional life.
    • Relevant: Supports hakarat hatov (gratitude) and relational harmony.
    • Timely: Start within one week and review progress after three months.

Green Hat (Creativity and Possibilities)

Light Aspect:

    • Inspires creative ways to integrate humility into life, fostering innovation in service and self-expression.

Shadow Aspect:

    • Creativity without grounding may lead to distractions or unrealistic applications of humility.

SMART Goal: Innovate Humility Practices

    • Observation: Humility can benefit from creative approaches to daily integration.
    • Feeling: A desire for dynamic and engaging humility practices.
    • Need: To infuse humility with fresh perspectives and ideas.
    • Request: Explore new rituals or activities that reflect anavah.

SMART Goal: Specific: Experiment with one new humility practice monthly (e.g., gratitude journaling, mindfulness exercises, or acts of kindness).

    • Measurable: Track practices and their perceived impact in a journal.
    • Achievable: Start with small, manageable innovations.
    • Relevant: Aligns with anavah as a dynamic and evolving trait.
    • Timely: Begin within two weeks and evaluate quarterly.

Blue Hat (Process and Control)

Light Aspect:

    • Ensures structured reflection and action, aligning humility with intentional practices and progress.

Shadow Aspect:

    • Overemphasis on structure may stifle spontaneity, making humility rigid or overly methodical.

SMART Goal: Create a Process for Sustaining Humility

    • Observation: A structured approach can sustain humility’s practice.
    • Feeling: A need for consistency in practicing humility.
    • Need: To create a sustainable system for integrating humility into daily life.
    • Request: Develop a framework for reflecting on and practicing humility regularly.

SMART Goal: Specific: Create a weekly review process where you reflect on one instance where humility was skillfully practiced and one area for growth.

    • Measurable: Complete this review weekly for three months.
    • Achievable: Dedicate 15 minutes each Sunday to this process.
    • Relevant: Aligns with seder (order) and intentional growth in anavah.
    • Timely: Begin this week and review the framework’s effectiveness monthly.

Summary

The Six Thinking Hats framework provides a robust way to explore anavah from multiple perspectives, ensuring a balanced and dynamic approach. By addressing light and shadow aspects with specific, measurable, actionable, relevant, and timely goals, this method ensures that humility is practiced skillfully and integrated meaningfully into all aspects of life.